In Paymex Ltd v HMRC (TC01210 – 10 June) a company (B) made supplies in connection with the establishment and supervision of individual voluntary arrangements for consumers who had fallen into financial difficulties.
HMRC issued a ruling that the company (P) which was the representative member of B’s VAT group was required to account for VAT on its supplies.
P appealed contending that it was making supplies of financial services concerned with debts which qualified for exemption under Article 135(1)(d) of EC Directive 2006/112/EC.
The First-tier Tribunal accepted this contention and allowed the appeal.
Judge Berner held that B’s services were ‘related to a financial transaction which has as its purpose both a change in the legal and financial situation of the debtor and creditors and the alteration and/or extinguishment of their respective rights...